December 15, 2007
-
This stuff just isn't canon
I was talking with one of my English readers the other day,
and we were talking about the anime Kanon (the 2006 remake). She didn't think
it was all that great, but that's her opinion and I respect that (blasphemer!).
Please allow me a little self-indulgence while I give you my reasons why I love
Kanon so much.The story - There isn't so much a story here, as there are
several stories. Rather than have twenty-four episodes that focus on one long,
drawn out story, they split the series into several "sub-stories"
involving each of the characters and how they relate to the protagonist. This
makes for a nice change of pace, as each of the stories is different and
entertaining. They all manage to blend in the perfect mix of humor, emotion,
and mystery. Granted, some of them may be farfetched, but that adds to the
allure. It's more entertaining than the same old school-age cliché that (while
I still love) is in almost every other anime of this type out there.The art style - I have to admit that Kanon is a very pretty
anime. It makes use of the "sad girl in snow" mechanic to great
effect. All of the character designs seem to fit their personalities well. The
childish Ayu has a childish hairstyle with a hairband, the sword-fighting Mai
has her hair tied back, and Yuuichi has, thankfully, a male haircut (to name a
few).The characters - This is the bread and butter for me. I love
almost all of the characters in the anime. Some more (Mai) than others
(Shiori), but they are all great. While Ayu and Makoto are very similar, most
of the other characters have their own unique personality and relationship with
Yuuichi, the protagonist. Yuuichi, while I'm thinking about it, is one of the
greatest male protagonists, and probably the greatest harem lead, to grace
anime. Rather than being a bumbling geek like so many other guys, he's actually
a more regular guy. He's also funny in a way that I can never emulate. Here are
my thoughts on some of the girls of the series.
Mai
My favorite character in the series. For a long time, I was
an Ayu fan. That is, until I started learning about Mai's story and seeing just
how awesome she is. Not only does she have two of my three main moé points
(ponytail and emotionless attitude), she even has some killer dance moves. Her
past is a sad one, and is probably a realistic representation of what would
happen if a true mystical healer would appear in the world today.Makoto / Ayu
In a way, these two characters are so similar that I can't
choose between them. I think Ayu may edge out Makoto slightly, but only because
I think "uguu~" sounds funnier than "auu~" Their
childishness and small mannerisms are just so motherf~ckin' adorable, that I
can't help but enjoy when they come onto the screen. They do, however, have some
of the most depressing stories in the series. This is balanced out by the fact
that Makoto is a "foxy lady" and a bit of a prankster.Nayuki
There are a lot of Nayuki fanboys out there, but I am not
one of them. Her story is one of the more entertaining, if only for the heavy
emotional trauma. I can also dig the blue hair and snow bunnies. The reason I
don't like her is because she always seems kind of out there. Oh, and incest is
just not cool, even for Pastafarians.Shiori
Shiori is just the most boring character in the series. I
mean, it was fun to learn about her back story, but ultimately she was just a
dull segment. Sorry, Shiori, but you're at the bottom of the list.I don't feel like writing any more, but that should give you
at least a small idea of how I'm thinking. I'm watching Clannad, which is from
the same company, but it just doesn't have the same kind of feel as Kanon. I
love it, but it just isn't as good. It must be the characters. They all seem
similar, and I can't really connect with any of them.
Comments (2)
Was it not I who said that Mai was cooler than Ayu, even before you watched Kanon? And yes, Shirori did nothing to the plot except waste a few episodes, Kaori howerver, was far more entertaining than Shirori by several levels (especially if you "watched" the Kanon drama cds). And then there is Amano... yeah...
But it didn't mean that I didn't like it...I just thought that it wasn't as good as Midori no Hibi or Inuyasha.
Mai - I loved the first time Yuuichi saw her in the school at night and she did her sword dance for the first time. I think her story as the second most moving one comapred to Ayu but it was one of the more realistic ones. And I like how she didn't talk much at first until she met Yuuichi.
Nayuki - Although her story isn't as tragic as Ayu she's always so cute. My favourite Nayuki moment was when she told Yuuichi the names of the cats on her PJs.
Ayu - "Uguu~" is definately cuter than "Auu~" and her story was the best because it was the most realistic and tragic. But what annoys me was the fact that at the end, it all became too unrealistic (I won't say more just incase I uber offend you).
Shiori - I can't believe you didn't like her! I felt really sorry for her and I loved that fountain moment.
Makoto - Although she was really cute in places and her story was more interesting than Shiori's, for some reason she got on my nerves a bit - I think it was because at the beginning she was so annoying and so it still stayed with me throughout the series (I definately won't say more because I'll mega offend you).
Kaori/Amano =( I don't think I need to say anymore