A quick overview: I'm currently embarking on an expedition into Christian theodicy by reading 21 Reasons Bad Things Happen to Good People by Liberty University department chair Dave Earley. This series of posts contains my thoughts as I read through. Comments and discussion are welcome and encouraged.
Introduction
Reason 1: The Reason No One Wants to Hear
This chapter begins with three assumptions the author has about the question "why do bad things happen to good people?"
- The world is full of evil
- God created the world
- Therefore, God is to blame
This seems to leave out some other assumptions, which makes it sound like a strawman. Here are a couple of assumptions I would include in the list:
- God is all-powerful, all-knowing, and all-good
- God has a hand in day-to-day life
Earley continues with Biblical response to the assumptions that he presented:
God created the world good
That sounds fair enough; it says so right there in Genesis. It does require a significant stretch of the word "good" to mean perfect and free of natural disasters, illness, crime, &c., but I can buy that.
God created people with the ability to choose
Again, fair enough. God wanted the love given to Him to be a choice. The problem I have is that the author assumes that the only choices are good and evil. Why would God give free will for the sake of "true love," but still make evil an option? Couldn't the choices have just as easily been love or not to love? Why make evil an option? Granted, I could assume that He wanted us to choose to both love Him and be good, but why would He want to have that as a choice? Bragging rights? To whom? If that is the case, I'm sure He's feeling quite embarrassed.
People chose evil
This points to the story of Adam and Eve, when they disobeyed God and ate from the tree of knowledge of good and evil. This story always seemed awkward to me. Sure they disobeyed God, but did they really choose evil, per se? At the time, they did not know the difference between good and evil. Choosing to eat from that particular tree and disobey God was a choice balanced against a tabula rasa of morals. Besides, given an infinite lifespan, they statistically would have eaten from that tree eventually, if only to stave off boredom.
Their choice brought evil into the world
Because Adam and Eve made the choice of evil, they ushered evil and sin into the world. This caused all of humanity to be besmirched by sin. I can't help but think about Adam and Eve's nudity. Isn't that wrong? They didn't realize it until they ate from the good-evil tree, but they were still naked. Why would their choice of disobeying God not have the same weight as choosing not to have any clothes on? Besides, didn't Jesus allow himself to be sacrificed to remove this sin? It shouldn't be an issue anymore.
Their choice has had lasting consequences
After Eve and Adam disobeyed God, mankind was not the only thing cursed. The world became cursed with sin and, by extension, with natural disasters and germs. This simply does not make sense. Why would nature revolt because of what man does? Isn't God in control of nature? He made the world perfect, so it should not be affected by man. Earley quoted the words from a guy named Cliffe Knechtle, who said that nature is revolting against us because we, quote, "told God to shove off." Having read Genesis, I see no such thing. We disobeyed because we didn't know any better. By "we," I mean Adam and Eve.
It goes on to blame humanity for much of the world's suffering, even dragging Hitler into it. It says I should not blame God for Hitler's massacres, which is probably accurate. I should blame God, however, for not doing more to stop it. Besides, how would this sort of thing flow out from humanity's sin? Magic? Since there's no magic, God can be the only cause. Even if it was some ungodly magic, shouldn't an all-loving, all-powerful god be capable of repairing and undoing the damage done to the world? While I suppose this would technically be a reason for bad things happening to good people, it still does not explain why God lets it happen.
Drunker than Skunks
This subheading relates the tale of the author walking in on his kids acting drunk after seeing it in the movie The Adventures of Huck Finn. He made a startling revelation, and here I am quoting, that "we are sinners by nature." In context, he meant "we" in terms of the entirety of humanity. This is even before Eve tasted of the forbidden fruit. We were created to sin. "We are sinners by nature." At this point, even a Faux-Christian like me would need to put up a [citation needed] tag. This sounds awkward for an all-loving god. I'll let this one slide and hope he makes no further mention of us being made to choose sin.

Recent Comments